Sunday, 7 February 2010

Site Breakdown: DeviantArt


Focus: Artists (digital and photography)

Members: 11 million


Users connect to eachother by commenting on their work (mainly photos)

no. users: 11million (info from wikipedia)


setup: community focused (primarily grouping and sharing common interest and information with strangers/new friends' rather than one-to-one connections with contacts that you already know)

Customisation: Can change colours/layout/content on their personal pages

Interaction: Join groups, discuss forum-style, comment on admired work, get advice in forums, find out about relevant events, polls, community news

Live feed: New content uploaded to website (by administrators), list of top photos, journals, videos, recent contributors and top contributors, most popular communities, individuals

Aliases: Yes, most members create their own screen name

Ads: Highly targeted, small and doesn't disrupt the design of the site.

Issues: I wanted to test if the images on the site are downloadable, and most are which is a copyright problem (they could make it more difficult to plagiarise). Also, when i opened up the download page norton came up with a huge alert saying that the site as unsafe.

I am interested in the interface difference between PC browser and mobile editions of sites, and how that this will affect the design....

Site breakdown: Buzznet

Focus:

Pop Culture i.e Celeb News; Music; The media; Photo, Video and Journal sharing

There is also the option to create polls, and share content and information with other users.

no. users: 10million (info from wikipedia)


setup: community focused (primarily grouping and sharing common interest and information with strangers/new friends' rather than one-to-one connections with contacts that you already know)

Customisation: Can change colours/layout/content on their personal pages

Interaction: Join groups, discuss forum-style, make friends with similar minded individuals, share events and media i.e. photographs etc

Live feed: New content uploaded to website (by administrators), list of top photos, journals, videos, recent contributors and top contributors, most popular communities, individuals

Aliases: Yes, most members create their own screen name

Case Study of My Free Implants


http://myfreeimplants.com/

I found this site quite disturbing and was really intrigued by it after watching a documentary of virgin called '100 men own my breasts'.

It is effectively 'cyber-begging' and there are lots of copycat sites springing up.

Basically, women go onto the site and create a profile. They then post pictures of themselves and ask then male members of the site to 'sponsor' them. The men have to purchase 'credits' to message the ladies to request custom outfits or to simply talk to them (at $1.20 per message i'd imagine that REALLY these add up!).

The women are prohibited from meeting men outside of the site (probably to protect the owners from responsibility if there are any problems. ironically they say that they just 'warn' people who violate the rules and only ban people in extreme cases). What i found most disgusting is that the women who do porn shots get their boob job faster, and men can say 'i'll sponsor you X amount of money if you dress up like a nurse' or whatever. The site is free for female members, but hugely expensive for men. The majority of the male users seem to be of the 'shut-in' profile i.e. no other female contact aside from the site, and from what it seemed, theyre guys with normal jobs i.e. not hugely rich and their interest in the site is detrimental to their financial health.

For more information, go here: http://myfreeimplants.com/how_it_works.asp

The strange thing about this site is that all the individual women are connected to the men, but the men aren't connected to eachother and neither are the women. One girl interviewed did say that she's met a couple of like-minded girls, but it seems ver limited i.e. she knows only 5 or 6 female members whilst in contact with hundreds of men.


I drew this quick diagram to show how the users are connected.

There is a catch though: If you stop being involved in the site before you reach your goal, you forfeit the money earnt and it goes to the founders (the men don't get refunds although they can transfer them t other women). Also, if the women never reach their pre-determined goal (i think its something like 5 grand for a UK boobjob or 3 grand for an overseas one), they can't take that amount and put it with their own money to buy a boob job. The site is highly exploitative: Selling porn to men under the guise of helping women get free boob jobs, and then the women have no choice what to do with their unsrupulously earned cash except to get bigger breasts. The site is technically social networking, but solely with the opposite sex and you communicate with 1. live instant messaging 2. live video conferencing 3. private messaging held in a hosted email account

Communication of presence: Outline of methods currently implemented

I don't use social networking sites as much as the average person, so i decided to do some research into the methods that they use to connect people. There's such a huge amount that i am limiting myself to the most popular, and selecting various niche interest groups.

Commonalities

1. Creating a profile: Adding photographs, Description etc.
2. Require a regular internet connection
3. Ability to leave messages for connected users and unconnected users
4. Connections: Seperation of people you know from strangers, able to easily connect to friends
5. Privacy settings (barrier to some/all information). This creates a sense of 'them' and 'us' with virtual social groups and contacts
6. Search function: ability to find people by different filters i.e. name, location
7. Life feed: You can see what activity is happening on the site. Some are user based i.e. noting what contacts have done; some are updates of new users; some are event and interest updates etc.
8. Targeted advertising (majority of sites don't charge for subcription so they rely on advertising revenue). Social networking sites are a gold mine as it allows for the placement of highly specialised ads to an advertisers target audience.
9. Your profile page (to easily access friends, your photos, make changes, contact people etc)

Differences:

Interface
1. 'Home page' - Some sites show you the live feed of other users actions at login, some take you straight to your 'profile/page'
2. Real/Alias: Some sites require the users to use real information and connect to real friends with their real name i.e. facebook and Classmates.com. Others can use aliases i.e. 'becca11480' on http://www.blackplanet.com/ which in a way encourages the 'fakeness' where you can make yourself whoever you want to be.
3. Where the social networking part is the secondary function of a site i.e. etsy (where users are there mainly to sell their goods, but can network and share ideas, the main part is the shop homepage, and lower down you can get to 'favourite sellers' etc


Overview of users

Tools:
-Live feed: Ability to filter recent updates by category not always there
-Forums (special interest/general interest). Some have pre-set boards, some allow users to create their own. The forum option is mostly available on interest focused social networking sites.
-Instant messaging (some have posting to your profile board, or private messing to an inbox hosted by the social network, or even real time messaging rivalling MSN)
-Video messaging and conferencing
-Blogging: Keeping other users updated. Some have the option to subscribe to updates i.e. twitter, some don't
-Layout customisation : i.e. changing colours, layout, adding things to your page i.e. music
-Block members
-Privacy settings: Option to disclose direct contact channels (i.e. posting your email address in public isn't allowed on http://myfreeimplants.com/ and you're not allowed to contact members outside of the site, whereas on other sites you can show any info you like). Also there is the choice to make your profile public/private which isnt available on a lot of sites.
-Geographical map of contacts
-Media: Some sites have a focus on media and allow you to easily share/see/discover music/videos
-Events: same as media, plus the option to post events
-Sale channels: some sites allow the purchase of things like music by independent artists, or garage sales and swap shops

Purpose

1. Dating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_online_dating_websites
2. Hobbies/Special joint interest i.e. photography, fashion i.e. lookbook.nu
3. 'Missed connections'
4. Situation/Jobs i.e. http://www.militaryspot.net/

Whilst having a look, many sites are situated around on feature that they do very well, and other functions expand out of this. Asides from facebook, most sites sell themselves bycreating interest based communities i.e. dating, finding old friends, sharing music, selling music, art etc.